Above The Law

Statistics from South Africa’s police watchdog show that officers implicated in crimes such as murder, rape, torture, and assault are almost never held accountable — even when the evidence against them is strong.

The Above the Law investigation built on the findings of the earlier Killing the Files series, shifting the focus from the failings of watchdog investigators to the managers and commanders in the South African Police Service (SAPS). It revealed the powers and loopholes these mid-ranking officers exploit to protect colleagues accused of serious crimes.

As this investigation showed, these cover-ups sometimes enabled violent officers to reoffend. The project was also notable for publishing the Police Accountability Tracker — an online dashboard containing details of more than 47,000 criminal complaints against the police in South Africa.

This project won the prestigious Global Shining Light Award (2023); was a category runner-up at Fetisov Journalism Awards (2022); and, was shortlisted for a Taco Kuiper Award for Investigative Journalism (2022).

Read the exposé which launched the project here.

Read a story which revealed the cover-up of a brutal murder by a problem officer here

May 11, 2021June 19, 2025

Above The Law

How SAPS protects the killers within its ranks

Explainer: The loopholes police use to protect their own from consequence

Viewfinder responds to Minister Cele: broken police discipline costs the poor dearly, but it can be fixed

Parliament rebukes SAPS for poor discipline as watchdog probes 794 killings by police

Police commissioner Sitole admits that SAPS discipline needs overhaul

Video: The Death of Phindile Ramncwana

Gauteng police have killed hundreds, but SAPS leave brutal cops unchecked

Video: The Death of Ishmael Gama

Cops who rape are rarely disciplined, watchdog data reveals. Many stay on the job.

Watch: Behind closed doors